We're excited to present a great new set of boards to classic movie fans with tons of new features, stability, and performance.

If you’re new to the message boards, please “Register” to get started. If you want to learn more about the new boards, visit our FAQ.

Register

If you're a returning member, start by resetting your password to claim your old display name using your email address.

Re-Register

Thanks for your continued support of the TCM Message Boards.

X

Kyle Kersten was a true friend of TCM. One of the first and most active participants of the Message Boards, “Kyle in Hollywood” (aka, hlywdkjk) demonstrated a depth of knowledge and largesse of spirit that made him one of the most popular and respected voices in these forums. This thread is a living memorial to his life and love of movies, which remain with us still.

X

Jump to content


Photo

Some favorite classic musicals


  • Please log in to reply
8 replies to this topic

#1 miki

miki

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 98 posts
  • LocationSomerville, MA U. S. A.

Posted 08 May 2017 - 05:12 PM

I try not to be negative if I can help it (and just focus on the positive). But the fact is I am not a fan of Audrey in MY FAIR LADY. It should have been Julie Andrews.

 

I love THE SOUND OF MUSIC but feel several sequences are too drawn out and the rear projection photography in some scenes is distracting (I know other musicals use it). I actually think the best moments are the non-musical ones with Eleanor Parker as the baroness. I find her the more interesting character in the story.

 

I still have yet to see WEST SIDE STORY. 

 

 

You should see West Side Story when you get a chance, especially if and when it plays on a great big, wide movie screen, in a real movie theatre, with the lights down low.  It's a real treat!


  • TopBilled likes this

#2 TopBilled

TopBilled

    Film Writing and Selected Journalism

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 39,553 posts

Posted 07 May 2017 - 05:23 PM

:blink:

 

I'm shocked to hear that. I thought that was one of those universally seen classics. I'm not sure of your musical tastes, but that one is usually liked. I enjoyed it, although I'm not a fan of the genre.

 

I prefer the 1930's musicals, personally.

 

My tastes in musicals run the gamut. Re: WEST SIDE STORY. I own a copy but never cracked it open. I found it in a $5 bin at Walmart about ten years ago and figured at that price, I should get it. I was thinking the story might have too many ethnic stereotypes. But if I suffered through MAME, I can handle anything! 


  • LawrenceA likes this

"The truth? What good is the truth if it destroys us all..?" -- Mady Christians in ALL MY SONS (1948).


#3 LawrenceA

LawrenceA

    Watchman

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 21,107 posts
  • LocationThe Wild Frontier

Posted 07 May 2017 - 04:06 PM

I still have yet to see WEST SIDE STORY. 

 

:blink:

 

I'm shocked to hear that. I thought that was one of those universally seen classics. I'm not sure of your musical tastes, but that one is usually liked. I enjoyed it, although I'm not a fan of the genre.

 

I prefer the 1930's musicals, personally.


  • TopBilled likes this

#4 TopBilled

TopBilled

    Film Writing and Selected Journalism

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 39,553 posts

Posted 07 May 2017 - 03:41 PM

I'm surprised that West Side Story and My Fair Lady weren't included on this list.  Ditto for The Sound of Music.

 

I try not to be negative if I can help it (and just focus on the positive). But the fact is I am not a fan of Audrey in MY FAIR LADY. It should have been Julie Andrews.

 

I love THE SOUND OF MUSIC but feel several sequences are too drawn out and the rear projection photography in some scenes is distracting (I know other musicals use it). I actually think the best moments are the non-musical ones with Eleanor Parker as the baroness. I find her the more interesting character in the story.

 

I still have yet to see WEST SIDE STORY. 


"The truth? What good is the truth if it destroys us all..?" -- Mady Christians in ALL MY SONS (1948).


#5 miki

miki

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 98 posts
  • LocationSomerville, MA U. S. A.

Posted 07 May 2017 - 03:04 PM

I'm surprised that West Side Story and My Fair Lady weren't included on this list.  Ditto for The Sound of Music.



#6 cinemaspeak59

cinemaspeak59

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 137 posts

Posted 24 April 2017 - 09:18 AM

I wanted to put together a list of musicals I enjoy. 

 

Alphabetically:

 

ANNIE GET YOUR GUN (1950). It features one of Howard Keel's best roles; and also one of Betty Hutton's best roles. The MGM production values are spectacular and so is Irving Berlin's music. I do have an issue with the writing of some scenes, especially where Annie has to learn her place in a man's world. But overall, it's a winner.

 

atlantic_city_1944_poster.jpg

ATLANTIC CITY (1944). My favorite Republic musical. Republic was the little studio that could do it all. The songs are fun and the performances are energetic. Constance Moore is so talented and I love watching her sing. There are some very good specialty numbers with ethnic performers. Dorothy Dandridge has a show-stopping moment. And so does Louis Armstrong.

 

THE BAND WAGON (1953). Probably Fred Astaire's best musical of the 50s, or at least it's what I believe. I always think of Nanette Fabray when this movie comes to mind; she should have been in more motion pictures.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-23-at-11-37-39-am.pn

BRAZIL (1944). Another excellent musical from Republic. The war years gave us the 'good neighbor policy,' so studios were making musicals that reached out to South American audiences. Tito Guizar, a Mexican, plays the main role. It also features beautiful Virginia Bruce as the female lead; and Edward Everett Horton has some good comic relief bits. It's an extravaganza with something for everyone.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-23-at-11-38-16-am.pn

CALAMITY JANE (1953). Doris Day considered this her favorite. It's definitely a crowd-pleaser.

 

CARMEN JONES (1954). The film is a bit uneven in spots; I think some of the dubbing is off. But Dandridge and Belafonte were never better. Otto Preminger had guts and I can't think of any other director during the repressed production code 50s who could have guided this passionate story as well as he did.

 

EASTER PARADE (1948). Pure perfection. Ann Miller nearly steals the show from Fred & Judy.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-23-at-11-41-41-am.pn

42ND STREET (1933). My favorite of the precode musicals. I think the earlier Busby Berkeley pictures at Warners are not quite as smooth. And this film just seems a little easier for modern audiences to enjoy, meaning it's dated but in a good way.

 

GIGI (1958). Certainly one of MGM's most successful films at the Academy Awards. I don't like the overall theme, but the performances are charming. And Louis Jourdan does not get enough credit.

 

GOOD NEWS (1947). Incredibly dated, even when it was first released. The studio (MGM) was certainly going retro with this one. But the dancing is fun; and I think June Allyson & Peter Lawford were always an appealing on-screen team. Plus I love Connie Gilchrist in this picture.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-22-at-7-31-44-am.png

THE PAJAMA GAME (1957). Another dated musical (most classic musicals are). But there's so much exuberance. I developed a new appreciation for Doris watching this film recently. It should be better known.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-23-at-11-54-11-am.pn

RICH, YOUNG AND PRETTY (1951). Honestly, Jane Powell musicals tend to be formulaic and sleep-inducing. But she's quite charming in this one, and Danielle Darrieux is fantastic as her exiled mother. I think the story about xenophobia is a little deeper than most musicals and I give Dore Schary's MGM credit.

 

SINGIN' IN THE RAIN (1952). It usually tops critics' lists. It's certainly at the top of my list. Except for an overly long dance number with Gene Kelly & Cyd Charisse near the end, which really gets in the way of the story, this musical can do no wrong. Jean Hagen should have had a supporting actress Oscar for her performance.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-23-at-12-03-25-pm.pn

SWEET ROSIE O'GRADY (1943). My favorite Betty Grable musical. A lot of her stuff kind of blends together. The stories were never thought-provoking or meaningful. But this picture has some good dialogue; and I think Grable works better with Robert Young than with any other leading man she had. 

 

TEA FOR TWO (1950). Like GOOD NEWS, this was another retro musical. Very dated by 1950, but Warners cast it well. Not only is Doris superb in her first top-billed musical, but the wisecracking supporting players are just as fabulous-- Eve Arden and S.Z. Sakall are both in scene-stealing mode.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-07-at-3-24-47-pm.png

TWO SISTERS FROM BOSTON (1946). I think this is my favorite June Allyson picture. I love everything about it. Her chemistry with Peter Lawford; the sisterly relationship she has with Kathryn Grayson; Jimmy Durante's fun style of comedy; Lauritz Melchior bringing a bit of class and sophistication to the proceedings; and the songs are very well produced. Plus, unlike other musicals, this one has a strong storyline.

 

TWO WEEKS WITH LOVE (1950). Ricardo Montalban is great in this film. He's another one people overlook for some reason. Plus I enjoy the pairing of Louis Calhern & Ann Harding as Jane Powell's parents. They also played a married couple in THE MAGNIFICENT YANKEE.

A great list of memorable musicals.  Yes, 42nd Street seems to be a time machine to early 1930s Broadway.  I think Jane Powell mentioned that Two Weeks With Love was her favorite film. 


  • TopBilled and rayban like this

#7 TopBilled

TopBilled

    Film Writing and Selected Journalism

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 39,553 posts

Posted 23 April 2017 - 04:51 PM

How can you talk about everybody's favorite college musical, "Good News" and not talk about Ray MacDonald's scene-stealing talents?.

 

I know, right! I also didn't mention Mel Torme. LOL


  • rayban likes this

"The truth? What good is the truth if it destroys us all..?" -- Mady Christians in ALL MY SONS (1948).


#8 rayban

rayban

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 2,168 posts

Posted 23 April 2017 - 04:06 PM

I wanted to put together a list of musicals I enjoy. 

 

Alphabetically:

 

ANNIE GET YOUR GUN (1950). It features one of Howard Keel's best roles; and also one of Betty Hutton's best roles. The MGM production values are spectacular and so is Irving Berlin's music. I do have an issue with the writing of some scenes, especially where Annie has to learn her place in a man's world. But overall, it's a winner.

 

atlantic_city_1944_poster.jpg

ATLANTIC CITY (1944). My favorite Republic musical. Republic was the little studio that could do it all. The songs are fun and the performances are energetic. Constance Moore is so talented and I love watching her sing. There are some very good specialty numbers with ethnic performers. Dorothy Dandridge has a show-stopping moment. And so does Louis Armstrong.

 

THE BAND WAGON (1953). Probably Fred Astaire's best musical of the 50s, or at least it's what I believe. I always think of Nanette Fabray when this movie comes to mind; she should have been in more motion pictures.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-23-at-11-37-39-am.pn

BRAZIL (1944). Another excellent musical from Republic. The war years gave us the 'good neighbor policy,' so studios were making musicals that reached out to South American audiences. Tito Guizar, a Mexican, plays the main role. It also features beautiful Virginia Bruce as the female lead; and Edward Everett Horton has some good comic relief bits. It's an extravaganza with something for everyone.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-23-at-11-38-16-am.pn

CALAMITY JANE (1953). Doris Day considered this her favorite. It's definitely a crowd-pleaser.

 

CARMEN JONES (1954). The film is a bit uneven in spots; I think some of the dubbing is off. But Dandridge and Belafonte were never better. Otto Preminger had guts and I can't think of any other director during the repressed production code 50s who could have guided this passionate story as well as he did.

 

EASTER PARADE (1948). Pure perfection. Ann Miller nearly steals the show from Fred & Judy.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-23-at-11-41-41-am.pn

42ND STREET (1933). My favorite of the precode musicals. I think the earlier Busby Berkeley pictures at Warners are not quite as smooth. And this film just seems a little easier for modern audiences to enjoy, meaning it's dated but in a good way.

 

GIGI (1958). Certainly one of MGM's most successful films at the Academy Awards. I don't like the overall theme, but the performances are charming. And Louis Jourdan does not get enough credit.

 

GOOD NEWS (1947). Incredibly dated, even when it was first released. The studio (MGM) was certainly going retro with this one. But the dancing is fun; and I think June Allyson & Peter Lawford were always an appealing on-screen team. Plus I love Connie Gilchrist in this picture.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-22-at-7-31-44-am.png

THE PAJAMA GAME (1957). Another dated musical (most classic musicals are). But there's so much exuberance. I developed a new appreciation for Doris watching this film recently. It should be better known.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-23-at-11-54-11-am.pn

RICH, YOUNG AND PRETTY (1951). Honestly, Jane Powell musicals tend to be formulaic and sleep-inducing. But she's quite charming in this one, and Danielle Darrieux is fantastic as her exiled mother. I think the story about xenophobia is a little deeper than most musicals and I give Dore Schary's MGM credit.

 

SINGIN' IN THE RAIN (1952). It usually tops critics' lists. It's certainly at the top of my list. Except for an overly long dance number with Gene Kelly & Cyd Charisse near the end, which really gets in the way of the story, this musical can do no wrong. Jean Hagen should have had a supporting actress Oscar for her performance.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-23-at-12-03-25-pm.pn

SWEET ROSIE O'GRADY (1943). My favorite Betty Grable musical. A lot of her stuff kind of blends together. The stories were never thought-provoking or meaningful. But this picture has some good dialogue; and I think Grable works better with Robert Young than with any other leading man she had. 

 

TEA FOR TWO (1950). Like GOOD NEWS, this was another retro musical. Very dated by 1950, but Warners cast it well. Not only is Doris superb in her first top-billed musical, but the wisecracking supporting players are just as fabulous-- Eve Arden and S.Z. Sakall are both in scene-stealing mode.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-07-at-3-24-47-pm.png

TWO SISTERS FROM BOSTON (1946). I think this is my favorite June Allyson picture. I love everything about it. Her chemistry with Peter Lawford; the sisterly relationship she has with Kathryn Grayson; Jimmy Durante's fun style of comedy; Lauritz Melchior bringing a bit of class and sophistication to the proceedings; and the songs are very well produced. Plus, unlike other musicals, this one has a strong storyline.

 

TWO WEEKS WITH LOVE (1950). Ricardo Montalban is great in this film. He's another one people overlook for some reason. Plus I enjoy the pairing of Louis Calhern & Ann Harding as Jane Powell's parents. They also played a married couple in THE MAGNIFICENT YANKEE.

How can you talk about everybody's favorite college musical, "Good News" and not talk about Ray MacDonald's scene-stealing talents?.


  • TopBilled and cinemaspeak59 like this

"I was born the day she kissed me.  I died the day she left me.  I lived a few weeks while she loved me." - Humphrey Bogart in "In A Lonely Place".


#9 TopBilled

TopBilled

    Film Writing and Selected Journalism

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 39,553 posts

Posted 23 April 2017 - 01:09 PM

I wanted to put together a list of musicals I enjoy. 

 

Alphabetically:

 

ANNIE GET YOUR GUN (1950). It features one of Howard Keel's best roles; and also one of Betty Hutton's best roles. The MGM production values are spectacular and so is Irving Berlin's music. I do have an issue with the writing of some scenes, especially where Annie has to learn her place in a man's world. But overall, it's a winner.

 

atlantic_city_1944_poster.jpg

ATLANTIC CITY (1944). My favorite Republic musical. Republic was the little studio that could do it all. The songs are fun and the performances are energetic. Constance Moore is so talented and I love watching her sing. There are some very good specialty numbers with ethnic performers. Dorothy Dandridge has a show-stopping moment. And so does Louis Armstrong.

 

THE BAND WAGON (1953). Probably Fred Astaire's best musical of the 50s, or at least it's what I believe. I always think of Nanette Fabray when this movie comes to mind; she should have been in more motion pictures.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-23-at-11-37-39-am.pn

BRAZIL (1944). Another excellent musical from Republic. The war years gave us the 'good neighbor policy,' so studios were making musicals that reached out to South American audiences. Tito Guizar, a Mexican, plays the main role. It also features beautiful Virginia Bruce as the female lead; and Edward Everett Horton has some good comic relief bits. It's an extravaganza with something for everyone.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-23-at-11-38-16-am.pn

CALAMITY JANE (1953). Doris Day considered this her favorite. It's definitely a crowd-pleaser.

 

CARMEN JONES (1954). The film is a bit uneven in spots; I think some of the dubbing is off. But Dandridge and Belafonte were never better. Otto Preminger had guts and I can't think of any other director during the repressed production code 50s who could have guided this passionate story as well as he did.

 

EASTER PARADE (1948). Pure perfection. Ann Miller nearly steals the show from Fred & Judy.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-23-at-11-41-41-am.pn

42ND STREET (1933). My favorite of the precode musicals. I think the earlier Busby Berkeley pictures at Warners are not quite as smooth. And this film just seems a little easier for modern audiences to enjoy, meaning it's dated but in a good way.

 

GIGI (1958). Certainly one of MGM's most successful films at the Academy Awards. I don't like the overall theme, but the performances are charming. And Louis Jourdan does not get enough credit.

 

GOOD NEWS (1947). Incredibly dated, even when it was first released. The studio (MGM) was certainly going retro with this one. But the dancing is fun; and I think June Allyson & Peter Lawford were always an appealing on-screen team. Plus I love Connie Gilchrist in this picture.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-22-at-7-31-44-am.png

THE PAJAMA GAME (1957). Another dated musical (most classic musicals are). But there's so much exuberance. I developed a new appreciation for Doris watching this film recently. It should be better known.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-23-at-11-54-11-am.pn

RICH, YOUNG AND PRETTY (1951). Honestly, Jane Powell musicals tend to be formulaic and sleep-inducing. But she's quite charming in this one, and Danielle Darrieux is fantastic as her exiled mother. I think the story about xenophobia is a little deeper than most musicals and I give Dore Schary's MGM credit.

 

SINGIN' IN THE RAIN (1952). It usually tops critics' lists. It's certainly at the top of my list. Except for an overly long dance number with Gene Kelly & Cyd Charisse near the end, which really gets in the way of the story, this musical can do no wrong. Jean Hagen should have had a supporting actress Oscar for her performance.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-23-at-12-03-25-pm.pn

SWEET ROSIE O'GRADY (1943). My favorite Betty Grable musical. A lot of her stuff kind of blends together. The stories were never thought-provoking or meaningful. But this picture has some good dialogue; and I think Grable works better with Robert Young than with any other leading man she had. 

 

TEA FOR TWO (1950). Like GOOD NEWS, this was another retro musical. Very dated by 1950, but Warners cast it well. Not only is Doris superb in her first top-billed musical, but the wisecracking supporting players are just as fabulous-- Eve Arden and S.Z. Sakall are both in scene-stealing mode.

 

screen-shot-2017-04-07-at-3-24-47-pm.png

TWO SISTERS FROM BOSTON (1946). I think this is my favorite June Allyson picture. I love everything about it. Her chemistry with Peter Lawford; the sisterly relationship she has with Kathryn Grayson; Jimmy Durante's fun style of comedy; Lauritz Melchior bringing a bit of class and sophistication to the proceedings; and the songs are very well produced. Plus, unlike other musicals, this one has a strong storyline.

 

TWO WEEKS WITH LOVE (1950). Ricardo Montalban is great in this film. He's another one people overlook for some reason. Plus I enjoy the pairing of Louis Calhern & Ann Harding as Jane Powell's parents. They also played a married couple in THE MAGNIFICENT YANKEE.


  • cinemaspeak59 and rayban like this

"The truth? What good is the truth if it destroys us all..?" -- Mady Christians in ALL MY SONS (1948).





0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users