• Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


Everything posted by jamesjazzguitar

  1. Nice to see someone making the point about remakes I have also been making, especially 'else considered the original outright, with the real original having been forgotten'. Many times I have to remind someone the 'original' movie they love so much more than a remake is also a remake!
  2. Remakes can be good and what may people forget is that remakes have taken place since movies started! Now I have to assume that most people that complain about remakes are really complaining about NON classic movies. e.g. movies made after 1960 or so. OK, I get that since the vast majority of movies I love are classic movies, but people do need to rememeber a movie like The Maltese Falcon is a remake. So what is a modern movie maker to do, only make movies from modern (new) original sources? I don't see why. Also, if a remake will get younger movie fans to check out a classic movie than this remake had value to the history of movies. Kate is very good so she just might be able to make the movie interesting. The goal isn't to be Crawford but for actors and directors to put their own stamp on classic source material.
  3. jamesjazzguitar

    Joan Crawford

    The movie was fun to watch since I hadn't seen it before and I really like all the top 3 stars, especially, Powell, but I wouldn't say it was a great movie. So typically MGM in that nothing really 'bad' was going to happen. For example, the threats of violence by the gang. In a Warner or RKO movie these sences would of had some dramatic impact but in an MGM movie they fall flat since there isn't any real darkness. Thus the movie is camp in so many ways but not camp enough to pull off.
  4. jamesjazzguitar

    The Blue Dahlia

    Thanks for the input. First I made a mistake when I mentioned Bette Hutton. I meant to say Bette Grable since, as you pointed out, she was a top star during the war years, with her movies, the poster, etc... More of an icon than someone known for their acting or the quality of her movies in my view. Yes, fame (being popular) and oscar don't always go hand in hand, but for Davis and Garson they did during that 5 - 6 year period. As you noted Garson fell fast, very fast, and Davis clearly cooled off at the end of her Warner days but then she did All About Eve; The type of role Garson never got after her peak. Warner also heated up Crawford's late period which might of been one of the reasons Davis left Warners. Good point about the different aproach MGM and Warners often took with their stars. I have always been more of a fan of the Warner style, as well as RKO and their movies during the 40s, than MGM but MGM did have many stars.
  5. jamesjazzguitar

    The Blue Dahlia

    I'm wouldn't say that Dorothy Lamour, Veronica Lake, Paulette Goddard and Betty Hutton were has 'big' as Bette Davis was during the war years with maybe the exception of Hutton for a very brief time. The big difference is that all of these women stared with other male stars while a Bette Davis picture was clearly a Bette Davis picture. Many of the male leads in Bette movies were not major stars (George Brett, the actors in The Letter, or Now Voyager, etc..). Plus if one looks at best actress nominations no one came close to Bette and Garson during their runs in the 40s. Thus to me these two were the top and everyone else was behind them in terms of being major stars during the war years.
  6. jamesjazzguitar

    The Picture of Dorian Gray

    I didn't see that movie since I'm not the West coast and that would be too early (and I work). So many movies, so little time!
  7. jamesjazzguitar

    The Blue Dahlia

    Yes, I knew there were others (I check my Paramount book before I replied since my memory is bad!), and I only listed those I felt were 'big' stars (of course Lamour was hugh with those Hope Crosby films). I love those gals but I don't know if they were big stars like Davis, Crawford, Garson, and others of the era, but someone else mentions Colbert and she was indeed someone I would define as a major star.
  8. jamesjazzguitar

    The Blue Dahlia

    In the late 40s' Paramount was the first studio to pick up Olivia De Havilland after Warner messed up in his lawsuit with her, and Olivia one two ocsars as best actress in Paramount movies. Paramount bigest star in the 30's was Lombard, but sadly they lost her and in the 40's their biggest stars were Ladd and Lake and Barbara Stanwyck. Warner and MGM had most of the major stars during the studio system days.
  9. jamesjazzguitar

    Katherine Hepburn

    I don't feel one open's a 'can of worms' by saying 'I don't like' an actor. One opens a can of worms with comments like 'that actor is a poor actor'. There are a lot of fine actors I don't like as much as other actors for the reasons given here; the roles they played, the movies and genres they were in, just how they carry themselves, their look etc.... For all of us these are very personal perferences. I LOVE Mithchum and I believe he is an underrated actor, but I wouldn't say he is as good as an actor as Tracy. But again in terms of who are my favorites, Mitchum ranks higher than Tracy mostly because I love noir and he is in some of my favorite noirs. Alan Ladd is another example; I can understand why critics say he was only an OK actor but most of the time I would rather watch a Ladd movie than a Tracy one because of the type of movie and character one finds in a Ladd picture. Yes, Kate did some noir (I have that book also, great book isn't it!). Glad to see Holiday mentioned. This is my favorite Hepburn film. Why? Well she doesn't play the standard Hepburn type (her sister in the movie is more the standard Hepburn type). The movie is funny but it does have a heart and is moving also.
  10. jamesjazzguitar

    Katherine Hepburn

    I saw Kate on the stage when I was 19 and it was indeed something special. The show was in LA and after the show she came out and talked. She mentioned that LA and her didn't have a 'love afair' but that really wasn't the case and that she had very special memories of the area and its people. It was night I'll never foget. To see someone of her talent live was a treat! I do understand why many of the characters she played could get on someone's nerves; The way she spoke and the 'air' in which she carried herself. But this is also what makes her so special. Bogie said it best when he talked about her and the making of the Queen. Yes, in some ways she was a pain, but the pain was worth it!
  11. jamesjazzguitar

    Odd Couples

    Ava was only a teen and the Mick was one of the biggest stars in Hollywood at the time. According to what Osborne said the other day, Mick went out every night after they were married and Ava stayed home and cryed. I would of been home every night!
  12. jamesjazzguitar

    The World of Alfred Hitchcock

    Eva plays most of her roles with a certain lack of emotion in her expressions and to me this 'fit' NBNW since she was a spy and was the girlfriend of the main bad guy but was really working for the government. Thus she couldn't show how she really felt and Eva was good at this. Not sure Grace would of been as believable.
  13. jamesjazzguitar

    The Blue Dahlia

    I have a Times magazine from December 1948 (because Olivia DeHavilland is on the cover for The Shake Pit), and in the mag is a review of jazz bebop music. It isn't a very friendly review and it implies this type of music wouldn't last. The music in The Blue Dahlia wasn't swing jazz but a faster type of post WWII jazz like bebop and many people didn't like this music because it was too busy. With regards to the term 'monkey music' I wonder if this isn't a racial term, since many of the musicians and band leaders playing bebop were of course black, while swing had a lot of white jazz musicians and most leaders were white (the Duke being the major exception). Anyhow I love movie but I will admit the Glass Key has a better story line. But as you noted with Ladd Lake and this post WWII setting, the plot was secondary!
  14. jamesjazzguitar

    The Blue Dahlia

    Yes, there are many coincidences in the movie but the fact that Ladd runs into Lake may not be one and Ladd mentions this latter in the movie when they drive to a hill and talk. I assume that Lake was following her husband because he was stepping out with Ladd's wife and that she knew what his wife had done to him. Thus she picked him up in the rain on purpose. Now I assume this because if Lake just happened to pick up a guy in the rain that is the husband of the gal Lake's husband is cheating with,,,,, well that is just impossible to believe! As you noted the plot isn't as important as the interactions of the characters and some of the sharp dialog.
  15. jamesjazzguitar

    The Picture of Dorian Gray

    Hatfield fit this part since his face didn't have much expression and that was a key part of Dorian; i.e. no feeling. But I saw him in another movie (don't remember which one), and he didn't have much expression in that either so I can see why he didn't go far.
  16. jamesjazzguitar

    The Picture of Dorian Gray

    Thanks for the enlighting info but I have to admit the over version of the story (i.e. it was a knock on 'the method'), was a lot more fun!
  17. jamesjazzguitar

    The Picture of Dorian Gray

    I believe the comment was 'why don't you try acting', because Dustin told Olivier that he had to 'get in the mood (correct mindset) and try to become the character before he could do the part.
  18. jamesjazzguitar

    The Lion in Winter

    Well maybe 'mostly' wasn't the correct term to use, but there is a lot of verbal sparing in the movie. I happen to enjoy it since both Kate and Peter do it so well, but I could see why others might not find it as enjoyable as me. For example, younger viewers that are used to action instead of dialog. Yes, the movie is like a chess match, but one thing I'm never sure about: Who one? It looks like it was a stalemate!
  19. jamesjazzguitar

    Favourite Ingrid Bergman films?

    Yes, that is interesting. I found the movie 'nice' but I wouldn't rate it as one of my favorites. Just not enough juice to keep me interested. Also as the part is written Ingrid has to act 'silly' and while that often works with younger women (i.e. is funny), it just looks silly with women over 40.
  20. jamesjazzguitar

    Favourite Ingrid Bergman films?

    I agree with your picks but I would add her first American film; Intermenzo with Leslie Howard. Love this movie. So lets make it top 5 favorites!
  21. jamesjazzguitar

    The Lion in Winter

    Very good point. Yes, there are movies, music, and other forms of Art that I don't enjoy but that doesn't mean they are 'junk'. It often just means that I'm not willing to be in the energy to enjoy these art forms (e.g. opera for me or for many people jazz, both which are developed tastes in my view like fine wine). And yes some art might just be of lesser quality but to call something that is respected and value by so many 'junk' is over the top. But, yea, I now remember that Garbo discussion. Like I said I can see why Lion might get on one nerves since there is little action and the movie is mostly just a verbal sparing between Kate and Peter. I happen to get a kick out of it but hey I liked Virginna Woolf also!
  22. jamesjazzguitar

    Frank Sinatra-Actor or no Actor?

    Yes, I did know what you said about Miles and many jazz 'cats' do the same thing. I also learned this many years ago from one of my jazz guitar teachers. Playing the 'head' (melody), on guitar is often difficult to get a hip sound. Yea, I was playing the right notes but not getting the right feeling. My teacher told me to play like Sinatra. Well I hadn't listened to him a lot so I didn't know what he meant. It was all about that great Frank phrasing. So I got some Frank CDs and started to listen and play along with them. At first I would be playing notes when Frank wasn't singing and vice-versa. Well this was because Frank pauses, for just a micro second at the perfect places. Ah, that phrasing.
  23. jamesjazzguitar

    FAvorite Film Director

    Howard Hawks followed closely by Billy Wilder.
  24. jamesjazzguitar

    Who Would You Like to See Featured As Star of the Month?

    I agree that there should be no repeats at least for 3 - 4 years. I would like to see Leslie Howard be SOTM since he never has and he is a first rate actor and star in my view. Yea he died young and thus didn't make a lot of movies like some others but there are enough first rate movies to have him be SOTM. Also a good idea someone here had was for character actors to get their due. Freature a guy and gal one month a year or something like that before repeating someone.
  25. jamesjazzguitar

    Frank Sinatra-Actor or no Actor?

    Yes, Sinatra didn't sing certain types of songs better than other singers and your Beatles examples is a good one. But no one sang the Cole songbook better than Frank in my view and his work with Riddle is one there as some of the best of all time.

New Members:

Register Here

Learn more about the new message boards:


Having problems?

Contact Us