Sign in to follow this  
qmuddy2

who'll replace robert osborne ?

41 posts in this topic

 

I would nominate to be the next primary host on TCM:

 

Lily Tomlin 

Burt Reynolds

Morgan Freeman

Eri Sendai

Will McKinley He is a blogger with ties to TCM

Film critic Mike D'Angelo

Film critic Ignatiy Vishnevetsky 

CineMaven She was once a regular in this forum and is an independent filmmaker. She is a very easy listen.

 

Freeman and Tomlin are probably too busy as of late.

 

Reynolds is probably too ill.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

CineMaven and yanceycravat, who have both been guest programmers, would be on my short list of potential hosts. Both have the presence, on-camera experience, film knowledge, and engaging personality necessary for the job.

 

Madeleine Stowe did an exceptional job as guest host, although I can't help wishing that she would get another role as perfect for her as Victoria on Revenge.

 

Annette O'Toole would be another top choice, either with or without Michael McKean. The back-and-forth between the two was a lot of fun, and both were quite knowledgeable about classic films.

 

Eddie Muller probably is too busy with noir-related activities to be a full-time host, but he is a fine addition to the TCM family.

 

Dave Karger did a good job as guest host, and he seems to appeal to at least one important TCM constituency, doesn't he?

 

No one will ever really replace Robert Osborne, but for the last couple of years Ben M has served very effectively as the main host of TCM, and will probably continue to do so for years to come. With Ben as the main host, TCM has the option of bringing in someone to take over Ben's previous role or else relying, at least for a while, on a variety of guest hosts. Some of the decision may be budget-driven.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Freeman and Tomlin are probably too busy as of late.

 

Reynolds is probably too ill.

 

Yep, Lawrence.

 

Burt was looking pretty frail last year at the Barrett-Jackson classic car auction in Scottsdale, and when he rolled up in that SMOKEY AND THE BANDIT Trans Am that went under the hammer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think the one thing that is essential to being a success as a TCM host (whether occasional or regular) is that the person doing it needs to be comfortable "reporting" on camera.  RO was an anomaly  --  a person who had often appeared on camera (he had done stand-up reports for LA stations, had appeared on the CBS Morning News and hosted The Movie Channel all prior to becoming the host of TCM) who also had an encyclopedic knowledge of classic film history.  It is highly unlikely that that kind of person will ever come along again. But, someone who is a film critic on broadcast or cable TV would be ideal. These people know how to convey information on camera   --  an absolutely critical skill for the job which a recent hire who shall go unnamed clearly will never have. One of the reasons that most of the actors (Matthew Broderick, etc. etc.) who have hosted on TCM do such a poor job is because there is a world of difference between being an actor and being a TV host/reporter.  An actor plays a character; a TV host/reporter "plays" himself and reports information. TCM should be checking out TV entertainment reporters as potential hosts if they seriously want to hire an additional person (or replace one who shall go unnamed!) I'd love to think a serious film scholar could do the job but a person like that would likely not have the needed on-camera skills to be successful.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Exactly.

 

Over the years I have been very impressed with Bob Mondello on NPR.  He is a superior writer, has an interesting voice and, from what I can tell online, looks good enough to be on TV.  Clearly he knows movies.   I don't about his ability in front of a camera, but he would be worth a serious look.

 

And while yes, while Madeleine Stowe did OK (I wouldn't say great...) I have serious doubts that any Hollywood A or B-list actor, even if they are on the downside of their careers, is going to do this job.

 

I don't like the idea of the rotating host.  It undermines the TCM "brand" and it means you end up with the good, the bad and the ugly.  There really is no upside to that approach, unless you're doing it as way to audition people for a full time gig.

 

Of course, TCM has had a LONG time to consider this.  Robert was clearly ill for some time.  Indeed, they should be ready to pull the trigger right now....

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No one can replace Robert Osborne and no one should...I am sure TCM has thousands of Robert Osborne movie introductions...and like those in the movies that have long passed, it would seem appropriate for TCM to continue Robert Osborne movie introductions, particularly, the true classics...as Robert would say, the magic of movies is that those in them never die...it would be a shame if TCM killed Mr. TCM himself by never re-airing Mr. Osborne's wonderful movie introductions. :wub:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 I have serious doubts that any Hollywood A or B-list actor, even if they are on the downside of their careers, is going to do this job.

 

 

So who suggested THAT?

 

You can't mean me because I said nothing about A or B list.  OR about being on the downside of their career.  But then, don't rule that out either....

 

For many years, a favored and highly respected local Detroit movie host was BILL KENNEDY who had only a few credits in major hollywood productions( his pride and joy being the executioner in JOAN OF ARC) and some small TV roles and doing the SUPERMAN voice over introduction.  But the people loved him.  He had knowledge of the old hollywood ropes and enough referrence materials to make any info about the movie he was showing more interesting.

 

But using old RO intros would be OK too.  But as they keep adding to the library, they'll have to get a new face to usher those in whenever they're shown.

 

 

Sepiatone

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry Vautrin, but BOB's family never spelled THEIR surname with that dumb British superfluous letter 'u', and UNLIKE the limey Ozzy's!

 

(...and so sorry, but your comment doesn't make sense, dude)

 

;)

Well now, perhaps Bob's family decided to drop the u when they

arrived in the States. He did make a joke about Ozzy when he

gave his speech for his star on the Walk of Fame. I'm fine with

no host at all, but if Ozzy isn't available, how about Geezer Butler?

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nPtorZ2k7Ak

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Now, ya know who WOULD make one hell of a great TCM presenter? And, a guy would doesn't seem to be doin' much lately in The Biz?

 

Uh-huh. A guy would LOVES classic movies.

 

AND, a guy who almost EVERYBODY agrees was THE best host of the Oscar ceremonies, and where he'd constantly exhibit said love and knowledge of movies.

 

Yep! I'm talkin' Billy Crystal here.

 

Wonder if he could be pressed into service? He seems the perfect fit to ME, anyway.

 

(...now, I, DARGO, would do it, but nobody knows ME from what Sheldon Leonard's Nick the bartender once says about George Bailey in Capra's Christmas perennial-"Adam's Off Ox", and so don't look for the TCM honchos to come knockin' on MY door any time soon, folks...and besides, I'm MUCH too damn cheap to sign onto that whole "Blacklot" thing, and where supposedly one can get their foot in the ol' door) 

 

;)

Well, I stopped watching the Oscars during his reign as host.  I hated those shows.  Other than the year they gave Blake Edwards an honorary award, I've never watched them, again.  Mostly, because I don't care about actors, today, and the majority of films nominated are just tedious, imo.  I'm okay with Ben as the lead host.  He is, anyway, so I hope they just keep it that way.  I also don't want Alec Baldwin!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One of my first choices obviously would be Leonard Maltin. Here are some other unique suggestions. None are high profile people, but all of them could be.

 

Karie Bible - Just a beautiful and highly charismatic lady with a profound passion for Noir, Golden Age and especially Silent Films.

 

Ginger Pauly - Lovely young gal, who is Vintage through and through. Loves the Golden Age and Silent Era's. Actress, Comedienne, Singer, interviewer. Boundless personality and charm.

 

Fernando Martin Pena' - His knowledge of the Cinema and in particular Spanish, Argentine, and the Silent Era is virtually without peer.

 

Hugh Munro Neely - An amazing historian who has personally discovered and restored many previously lost films. Extremely personable. His knowledge of the Silent and Golden Era's is impeccable. 

 

Bob Fells - If you amalgamated together Bob Dorian and Robert Osborne he would look like Bob Fells. Bob belongs on TCM. Few people know more about Classic Cinema anywhere.

 

Jorge Finkielman - Jorge is literally a one man archive beyond compare. Has restored more Classic film images Lobby's, Posters, stills, etc, then anyone else I can think of. Jorge makes many so called historians sound like novices by comparison. 

 

Chuck Tabesh - Chief TCM Programmer from the beginning. Hey, Chuck when are you actually going to appear on camera? I've been waiting for well over a decade! Don't be shy!

 

Ron Hutchinson - Head of The Vita-phone Project. Great knowledge of Silents and Pre-code cinema. Very personable guy.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been observing this thread with quiet bafflement for some time now. It appears no one else is ever going to say it, so here goes: this whole thread seems to be insult as it doesn't acknowledge someone already replaced Robert well over a year ago, assuming the bulk of the hosting duties even during Robert's final months on the network.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been observing this thread with quiet bafflement for some time now. It appears no one else is ever going to say it, so here goes: this whole thread seems to be insult as it doesn't acknowledge someone already replaced Robert well over a year ago, assuming the bulk of the hosting duties even during Robert's final months on the network.

 

Assuming there is a chain of command one would assume Ben automatically moves up to the top spot. I don't think anyone is disputing that. Nor do I think anyone is trying to be insulting.

 

It seems clear the network is interested in someone sharing the duties with Ben or he'd have been going solo for the last several years. Maybe we're all wrong. We've sort of gotten used to there being two night time hosts trading off intros and naturally figured there might be someone in the wings to be that "other host".

 

To many of us Robert Osborne could never be replaced by anyone, respectfully, not even Ben. But it seems clear the network decided ten or eleven years ago that doing all those intros is too much for one person.

 

Yancey

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, maybe I misunderstood. It seemed to me the thread was implying who will replace Robert Osborne as the main host, when that question has already been answered. But as far as just hiring a new host in general, I sort of feel like that's already happened. Ben will do the most hosting, and you'll see various others mixed in: Dave Karger, Eddie Muller, Tiffany Vazquez and occasional celebrity guest hosts such as Dana Delaney, Iliyana Douglas and Robert Wagner.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, maybe I misunderstood. It seemed to me the thread was implying who will replace Robert Osborne as the main host, when that question has already been answered. But as far as just hiring a new host in general, I sort of feel like that's already happened. Ben will do the most hosting, and you'll see various others mixed in: Dave Karger, Eddie Muller, Tiffany Vazquez and occasional celebrity guest hosts such as Dana Delaney, Iliyana Douglas and Robert Wagner.

They shouldn't attempt to insert someone similar to Osborne in the main slot. Ben will do just fine.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Now, ya know who WOULD make one hell of a great TCM presenter? And, a guy would doesn't seem to be doin' much lately in The Biz?

 

Uh-huh. A guy would LOVES classic movies.

 

AND, a guy who almost EVERYBODY agrees was THE best host of the Oscar ceremonies, and where he'd constantly exhibit said love and knowledge of movies.

 

Yep! I'm talkin' Billy Crystal here.

 

 

 Hey, Billy, you're on  . . .

 

Oscars-2012-Billy-Crystal-007.jpg

 

The clown with his pants falling down

Or the dance that's a dream of romance

Or the scene where the villain is mean

THAT'S ENTERTAINMENT!

 

Now there's Rick, who calls Ilsa his chick

Or, yes, Rhett, loving Scarlett you bet

And King Kong, oh man is he strong

THAT'S ENTERTAINMENT!

 

Yes there's Bing, he's the master of swing

And the Duke, his horse it don't spook

Or Monroe, on the screen does she glow

THAT'S ENTERTAINMENT!

 

TCM is a stage; that stage is a world of EN-TER-TAAAAAIN-MENT!

 

How am doing, folks, and welcome to TCM! Have we got a great film for you tonight . . .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How about an array of "guest" hosts like Julie Andrews introducing musicals, Kevin Costner introducing westerns and etc. for the silents and classic old films some revered star from long past.  This could continue until an official host is chosen.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

Returning Members:

Register Here

Learn more about the new message boards:

FAQ

Having problems?

Contact Us