Firstly, allow me to address a few of the other comments. In response to one comment which asked why I waited until this year to complain, my answer is that the omission has bothered me for many years, but the omission alone in years past was not enough to provoke a direct response from me; however, it is only this year that TCM chose to have a Christmas movie marathon and a Frank Capra movie marathon in the same month, which I simply consider an insult to injury, if you will. I merely feel that the film's absence is underscored as it has not previously been due to the Capra marathon, so I feel that perhaps they should have had the Capra marathon either in November or January or sometime else entirely.
Also, another user said the following:
"I expect this holiday season to be an especially "tetchy" one. Beyond the No *It's A Wonderful Life? threads I am bracing for the "Why no White Christmas?", "Why no The Bishop's Wife?" and "Why no A Christmas Story?" comments.
Recommending Remember The Night and It Happened On Fifth Avenue will only go so far.
Kyle in Hollywood"
For the sake of time, I feel the need to pick my battles; I can't afford to get riled up about everything. But now that the subject has been brought up, I am indeed upset about the absence of not only "It's a Wonderful Life", but almost all of the perennial Christmas classics. Now, I know there will be some sanctimonious film critics who dub these so-called "classics" as kitsch or hackneyed and only enjoyable to those of crass tastes, but I do not concur! I myself have seen nearly all the classic films as well as many lesser-known films; however, I have come to realise that, in many cases, the classics are considered classics for a reason. And, while NBC may own the rights to some, they could not own every last one of them. I would love to see "The Bishop's Wife" on TCM this year; in fact, I suggested it on this very website. They showed it last year, I distinctly remember. But why do they never show such classics as "Holiday Inn" or "White Christmas"? I think it is a fair question. And why can I never remember them having shown the 1951 version of "A Christmas Carol", which is arguably the definitive version. The only Christmas films that TCM seems to have shown in recent years without fail are "Christmas In Connecticut" (1945), "A Christmas Carol" (1938) and "Meet Me In St Louis" (1944). I am certainly not complaining about this, as both "Christmas In Connecticut" and "Meet Me In St Louis" are amongst my all-time favourite films; but I do not think they should show these to the exclusion of any others. As for "Miracle on 34th Street", I know NBC must have the rights to this since they show it annually after the Parade on Thanksgiving Day, although on a completely unrelated tangent it seems even NBC has opted not to show "Miracle on 34th Street" this year on Thanksgiving, and is instead showing "Dr Doolittle" in its place (as if anyone wants to see that on Thanksgiving!), which bothers me as much as TCM's omission of "It''s a Wonderful Life"; but I digress (though I'd like to hear from anyone on the "Miracle on 34th Street" subject too, if you are interested).
The question I have is indeed "why"? I truly do not think it would be too much to ask of TCM for it to appease the endlessly-sentimental, nostalgic portion of its viewers who revel in watching holiday classics on TCM, by the fire with snow outside, sipping glasses of eggnog! I'd love to see Robert Osborne's input on a few of the classics that you just can't get from a DVD! I really feel that, at the very least, they could throw in just a few more perennial favourites each year for good measure--that's all I'm asking for!