sdgarcia

I totally agree, MacRae's voice was the best, not one can compare, or even come close. Gordon MacRae was amazing!

I totally disagree, let the original Musicals stand on their own, besides the remakes are rarely better.

Isn't he gorgeous?

Ain’t he gorgeous?

Are there any fans out there that agree, Gordon MacRae was one of the best singers of his era, and was underated as a singer and actor, and not accorded the fame he deserved?

I agree, you can not replace the great voice of Gordon MacRae, his range was amazing. There is no one who came, or comes close to the emotion he could convey, with just a simple change in pitch like Gordon MacRae. Remaking this great musical would be a mistake, let it stand on it's own.