Jump to content
Search In
  • More options...
Find results that contain...
Find results in...

Sir David

  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won



About Sir David

  • Rank
    Advanced Member

Profile Information

  • Gender
  • Location
    Columbus, Ohio

Recent Profile Visitors

834 profile views
  1. I think part of the appeal of Noir is the theme of the average Joe getting in above his head, making decisions that will change his life forever and often not in a positive way. For me the major problem with Rooney is that he's simply not "average": when he snarls at a bad guy, I can only imagine their reaction to be a laugh followed by something swift and violent, we simply cannot take Rooney seriously as a Noir protagonist.
  2. Caged I have to say that I enjoyed this more than the testosterone-fuelled man-movie "Brute Force". It was more nuanced in it's portrayal, more balanced. To me it was more Noir too - we follow the lead from a scared, new-fish, innocent girl, through a huge change to the hardened and cynical woman who leaves the prison a scant 15 months later: in true Noir style she pays for her mistake in the past, not with death but with an obvious descent from good to bad, and the prospect of ending up like the old lifer who tried to turn her away from her path into crime. Eleanor Parker was excelle
  3. The Gangster So stagey and hammy! A pretty dreadful B-movie, imho. Nothing really happens...slowly. And then the protagonist dies. Still, it really looked great and hit so many Noir buttons with it's visuals. I just wish I'd watched the thing with the sound off! It had a great (if largely wasted) cast too, which came as a surprise. But the male lead was about as exciting to watch and expressive as a cigar-store Indian, and the female lead (Belinda, Melita, Viagra, Ryvita?), although she had scene-stealing pins, was pretty uninspiring otherwise. Best thing about it? Shabunka's pre
  4. The Strip Oh, my! Never wanted to watch this in the first place but for the sake of watching all the movies on the course (I'm up to 95) I fixed myself a stiff drink, gritted my teeth, and hit the play button. Mickey Rooney: no no no. How are we supposed to take him seriously as a Noir protagonist at 5'2"? I don't want to be height-ist here, but... Musical Numbers without a real link to the plot: too many, too samey! I mean, the film was short enough (apologies for the pun) without 10-20 minutes of it being musical numbers! Paper thin plot: definitely. Femme fatale: more
  5. The People Against O'Hara Catching up with films I missed but have on DVR, I finally came around to watching this. It was okay, I guess...I can see why Eddie Muller concentrated so on the visual aspect of the film, because certainly the plot itself was a little creaky. Would any real life attorney throw so much away on sheer blind belief in O'Hara, when so much evidence (soooo much evidence) pointed to the accused's guilt, and even the dumb lummox himself would not do anything to help his own case? Sad to say they telegraphed Spencer Tracy's demise in the movie with his late phone cal
  6. Berlin Express A Realist movie, and - for me - a very important movie. I've seen many photos of post-war ruination but seeing it in a movie setting really brought home just how devastating it must've been to have had to live in such a setting after the war. How did the people cope? How did they live? How difficult it must've been to have rebuilt...I don't even know if I would have know how or where to begin. I wonder too if the struggle to survive (and the personal selfishness - in the form of basic survival) it must have engendered sowed the seeds of the future decline of so many of the s
  7. Tomorrow is Another Day Finally got around this movie... seems such a long time since the early days of the course: that's an awful lot of dames, dubious decisions, double-dealing, death and despair! This one didn't have much in the way of death, but the one it did have was crucial in that it caused our protagonists to exercise some of those wonderful dubious decision making skills we've so grown to love! They run because they thought they'd killed a cop - well, they did but for some highly improbable reason he makes a death-bed confession that it was in self-defense. Right. Like that
  8. I like your summary here, but would disagree about one thing. You say the only psychopath is Munsey, I would argue that - to some extent - Burt Lancaster's character, Joe Collins actions show him to be equally psychotic. He's in some way like a mirror image to Munsey and they hate each other with such passion because they recognize (and hate) the same traits in the other that is also inside them. Collins' violence isn't expressed as overtly, but think about it: the prisoners seem as awed by Collins as they are cowed by Munsey - prisons run on simple fear and the survival of the fittest and
  9. Side Street I almost didn't watch this one: I'm not a fan of Farley Granger or Cathy O'Donnell (especially) but I'm actually quite glad I did as it turned out to be a fairly enjoyable B-movie. If I'd known too that Jean Hagen and Charles McGraw were in it I would've watched it far sooner, it's just a shame they had such small parts! The film included some wonderful visuals of New York during the big car chase at the end of the movie: notably the bar-like shadows cast between the canyons of the downtown skyscrapers. It was actually fascinating to see the city in the 1950s like that, I'v
  10. Kiss Me Deadly It's amazing how quickly how society in the 50s changed: this film, made in 1955 is just so different in style and attitude to the Noirs of the late 40s and even the beginning of the 50s. Where did all the hats go? Gone too is the glamour of the female of the species, along with the nobility and decency of, well, pretty well everyone: everyone just seems to want more and everyone has a price. I have to say I don't like it as much. Mind you, there is a happy ending (I suppose), but I think - like many people - that the truncated ending with the ambiguity over whether Ham
  11. I thought this was an excellent movie: Jake Gyllenhaal was tremendous as the haunted-looking and incredibly creepy "hero", prepared to do anything to progress in his chosen sphere. It was an incredibly dark movie, with the vast majority of it taking place at night (did we see the daylight at all, I don't remember?) and no doubting it's Noir credentials here. But, unlike the Noirs from the classic period, Karma isn't lurking around the corner waiting for him: he doesn't pay for his sins and in fact prospers from his deviousness. No-one else may come out of this movie in any way happy but t
  12. Act of Violence I think I must be all Noired out after watching this, my 86th film from the schedule, because I simply couldn't care less about the two protagonists. Van Heflin deserved his Noir-come-uppance for being a stool-pigeon, of course, but they never made Ryan at all sympathetic enough for us to really care that he was a good guy hell-bent on revenge, he was simply there. It's as if they expected the limp alone to make us think he was threatening but at the same time deserving of getting revenge for it and his happy ending. Personally, I think it would have been a far better f
  13. I do find I prefer the RKO Noir output but, yes, this one was a real dud! It seemed to me they couldn't work out whether to make a drama, a musical or a comedy and ended up with none of them.
  14. Really? I'm going to have to get that book as I really need to know how they class Party Girl as Noir! (Perhaps too, it might shed some light on the awful "A Woman's Secret", which I had the misfortune of watching today.) All I can say is that they can't be too sure themselves if they feel the need to spend so much time on it! I missed The Damned Don't Cry, sadly. Was it on TCM? Shame, I feel I've seen too many happy endings recently, I need some Noir despair!
  15. A Woman's Secret Or, much ado about nothing! What a dreadful movie. The only mysteries here for me were: 1. How did I remain awake? 2. Who gave the green light on the whole mess in the first place? Wikipedia states that Howard Hughes held up the release "for no apparent reason". I disagree. I think the very apparent reason is that he had actually watched the thing! 3. Why is it on a list of Noirs? The only good thing about it was...no...there was nothing. I can only think someone carried out a heist on this whole course and smuggled this movie into the line-up.
© 2021 Turner Classic Movies Inc. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Settings
  • Create New...