[Musicals ! Please inform me!]

Oh wow thanks, i feel so welcome here! M... uneducated girlie fans... its a scary thing, i guess it just really offened me when that girl acted that way. Yeesh!! I think ill be a floating through here more often anyway, civilized people, its wonderful!

 

Celia

[Musicals ! Please inform me!]

So i was on this dumb fan website messageboard and this girl commpletly bashes me ( it was a thread on favorite movies)!!! this is what she says to me:

 

"""Quote:

citizen kane

Some like it Hot

Sining in the rain

Sunset boulevard

( im a big fan of classics and musicals so they all go on my list... lol)

 

 

Just a little helpful hint, Singing in the Rain technically isn't a musical, so you might wanna think before you call it one. A movie-musical is not a musical unless it was first written and composed for stage, but later adapted to film. Yes, sorry to break your hearts, but The Wizard of Oz is not a technical musical because it was a movie before it was a play. "

 

ok so she took part of my post the "quote" and she said that stuff about singin in the rain. fist off i was wondering if this techincality of hers is right, but even if it is correct no one ever puts much thought in that! Also I was wondering isnt sining in the rain up there on the greatist musicals of all time!! Oh man i am so offended can someone please inform me!!

 

Thanks,

celia