I would have to select Godspell as my favorite musical, but that is primarily due to my personal connection to it. My church had performed this musical every two years as a sort of rite of passage for the youth and high school choirs and my daughter performed in it twice, first time as a member of the chorus and then in 2013 as Peggy singing "By my Side". We watched the movie multiple times and I went to many rehearsals, so participating in preparation for performances was immersive and exciting. Unfortunately, the church discontinued performing this musical after our previous music director retired - this musical makes me melancholic.